In response to questions posed by our members concerning the financial toll wrought by a global health pandemic on local communities, the Municipal Assistance Center (MAC) has assembled the following information related to municipal efforts to potentially lessen the severity of COVID-19.
For additional information about municipal emergency planning assistance and coordination, please visit our Coronavirus Resources and Recommendations webpage, www.vlct.org/coronavirus.
Individual members may not merely show up at the town office and sign payment orders at their convenience as this would constitute a violation of the Open Meeting Law (OML). The OML requires a majority of selectboard members to take an action or make a decision (e.g., sign an order approving payment), only within the context of a duly warned open meeting. 1 V.S.A. § 172. There are two exceptions to the above general rule. Both exceptions require the selectboard to meet at least once, though such a meeting could occur by electronic means (see “Open Meeting Law and COVID-19 Response FAQs” at: https://www.vlct.org/resource/open-meeting-law-and-covid-19-response-faqs.
- First, the selectboard can vote at a duly warned meeting to approve certain payments in advance so that there is no need for members to actually sign orders. Such a vote must identify the person(s) to whom payment is to be made and the purpose(s) for that payment. The treasurer may then use a certified copy of the minutes of the meeting as full authority to make the approved payment. 24 V.S.A. § 1623(a)(2).
- The second exception allows the selectboard to authorize one or more members to review and approve orders on behalf of the entire board. A vote to give such authorization must take place at a duly warned selectboard meeting and must be reflected in the meeting minutes. A motion to give such authorization might be phrased as, “I move that we appoint [insert name(s) of the legislative body member(s)] to approve and sign orders for [insert types of claims that the person has authorization to approve such as “payroll,” “operating expenses,” etc.] for [insert period of time].” Any orders that are approved under this authority must state definitely the purpose for which they are drawn. The full selectboard must later be provided with a record of all the orders approved. 24 V.S.A. § 1623(a)(1).
Relatedly, in the event that there are so many vacancies on the selectboard that a quorum cannot be achieved, the remaining member(s) have the authority to draw orders for payment of continuing obligations and necessary expenses until the vacancies are filled. 24 V.S.A. § 961(b).
The Legislature recently passed Act 102 (S.344), which modifies tax and tax penalty laws. What does Act 102 (S.344) temporarily change?
Act 102 (S.344) allows selectboards, without voter approval, to:
- reduce the municipal property tax rate;
- extend or establish a new time and method for paying taxes;
- establish a grace period for, reduce, or waive interest, fees, and penalties associated with late tax payments.
These acts may be taken by majority vote of the selectboard so long as the vote occurs throughout the duration of the declared state of emergency. If voted, any such action would expire on January 1, 2021.
Yes. Act 102 (S.344) gives selectboards temporary authority to reduce, but not increase, the municipal, but not the education, property tax rate. This means that selectboards would not have to set a tax rate necessary to raise the appropriations approved by the voters at town meeting. Instead, selectboards will now have the flexibility to only raise that revenue from taxes which is necessary to fund its reduced operations.
Yes. Act 102 (S.344) gives selectboards temporary authority to either extend or establish a new time and method for the payment of the municipal and statewide education property tax collected from taxpayers. Please be aware that the new law does not apply to any deadlines, penalties, or interest imposed on a municipality with respect to payment of the statewide education property tax due to the State or a school district.
Anyone can request an abatement of taxes, penalties, or interest under 24 V.S.A. § 1535 so long as one of the statutory criteria has been satisfied. One criterion a person can use to request an abatement is an inability to pay their taxes or charges, interest, and collection fees. 24 V.S.A. § 1535(a)(3). Although the ability to abate exists, it must be requested, it is up to the discretion of the board of abatement (selectboard, town clerk, justices of the peace, listers, town treasurer), and it is not required that the board abate taxes or charges, interest, or penalties, even if the person requesting an abatement meets one of the criteria under 24 V.S.A. § 1535. It is important to note that if the board of abatement is anticipating hearing many abatement requests and considering abating a large portion of taxes, the selectboard should consider how it will cover any associated budget shortfall and otherwise meet its existing financial obligations. See “Can the Selectboard Borrow Money Without Voter Approval?” at https://www.vlct.org/can-selectboard-borrow-money-without-voter-approval-0.
Yes, separate from abatement, Act 102 (S.344) gives selectboards temporary authority to establish a grace period for, reduce, or completely waive any penalty, interest, or fee that would otherwise be imposed on taxpayers for the late payment of the municipal or statewide education property tax.
We have not held our annual meeting yet this year, so we don’t have a budget in place. What can we do?
The Legislature enacted Act 105 (H.947) to address towns that have yet to hold their annual meeting. This law, which is in effect for the duration of the declared state of emergency, gives selectboards the temporary authority to adopt a budget and establish a tax rate for the next fiscal year without the need to hold a town meeting to obtain voter approval. Therefore, the selectboard can vote at its own duly warned meeting to finalize both a budget and a tax rate for this year so long as the vote is taken during the declared state of emergency.
The delinquent tax collector (DTC) and selectboard together could come up with a COVID-19 related temporary policy to address tax sales. Such a policy could modify the DTC's typical policy on how and when the DTC will proceed to tax sale (e.g., extending the timeframe or circumstances of when the DTC typically initiates a tax sale in order to give delinquent taxpayers more time to pay).
It depends on the deadline but note that the Vermont Tax Department has extended some property tax assessment related deadlines and may continue to make changes to these processes. Please go to https://tax.vermont.gov/coronavirus/towns for updates on deadlines, contact information for PVR District Advisors and other helpful information. PVR recommends directing questions or comments to your District Advisor or emailing firstname.lastname@example.org. It will continue to update its webpage with frequently asked questions.
How do we continue to fund existing service levels and pay our bills without any incoming tax revenue?
The COVID-19 pandemic is taking a financial toll on everyone, not the least of which includes municipalities. As people experience a loss of income due to unemployment and decreased revenues as a result of social distancing, towns will see a corresponding decline in timely tax payments, an increase in requests for tax abatement, and lower local tax revenues. Despite reducing service levels and staff hours, towns will still have their own outstanding financial obligations to meet including payroll, matching funds for state and federal grants, bond and lease payments, etc. The combination of these circumstances raises the likelihood that towns will need to borrow in order to get by, at least in the short term.
The difficulty with borrowing during a public health pandemic is that it requires voter approval at an annual or special town meeting and mass gatherings are not a luxury that we can presently afford. 24 V.S.A. 24 V.S.A. § 1786a. The President has released guidelines that call for people to avoid gathering in groups of as small as ten (10) or more people. Even if a meeting were called, people would correctly be reluctant to attend and participate which could undermine and even skew the results of such a vote.
Fortunately, the law recognizes nine situations in which a selectboard may borrow funds without voter approval.
A public vote to borrow is not required in the following instances:
- Borrowing to paying current expenses so long as the term is one year or less. 24 V.S.A. § 1786. There is no statutory definition or explanation of a “current expense.” Our rule of thumb is that a current expense is one that will be paid for in a year or less. A current expense could arise from provision of a service or from the acquisition of a public improvement or asset. In our opinion, simply because something is an asset or a public improvement does not mean that it cannot be considered a current expense under 24 V.S.A. § 1786. We view the term of the note (one year or less/more than one year) as the defining characteristic.
- Borrowing in anticipation of taxes so long as the term is one year or less and the amount borrowed does not exceed 90% of the municipal taxes assessed for that year. 24 V.S.A. § 1786.
- Borrowing in anticipation of the sale of bonds as long as the term is one year or less. 24 § V.S.A. § 1773(a).
- Borrowing in anticipation of grants as long as the term is one year or less. 24 V.S.A. § 1773(c).
- Borrowing for the purchase of tools, equipment and materials necessary for the construction, maintenance or repair of highways and bridges for a term of five years or less. 19 V.S.A. § 304(a)(3); 24 V.S.A. § 1786a(b).
- Borrowing from the State Municipal Equipment Loan Fund for the purchase of construction, fire, emergency or heavy equipment or vehicles. 19 V.S.A. § 304(a)(3); 24 V.S.A. § 1786a(b); 29 V.S.A. § 1601.
- Alternative financing of personal property, fixtures, technology and intellectual property. 24 V.S.A. § 1789. The selectboard may enter into leases, lease-purchase agreements, installment sales agreements, and similar agreements to acquire assets for the municipality either singly or as a participant in an interlocal contract. Such an agreement, however, must contain a “non-appropriation clause” that states that the annual payments by the municipality must be approved by the voters.
- Borrowing to retire a deficit with “refunding bonds.” The selectboard may opt to convert a deficit into debt by issuing municipal refunding bonds for an amount equaling the deficit. 24 V.S.A. § 1771. This bond creates a replacement debt which will be paid off over a period of years.
- Borrowing for the preparation of engineering studies or plans for public water/wastewater supply systems/facilities provided such debt is included in any subsequent public authorization of municipal indebtedness to construct the project for which the planning loans were used
Ordinarily, no you can’t or at least State law does not explicitly recognize your authority to do so. 19 V.S.A. § 312. Act 133, however, temporarily suspends this prohibition for the duration of the declared state of emergency and gives selectboards the express authority to borrow monies appropriated from property taxes for highway expenditures and use them for general fund purposes, and vice versa. This temporary authority applies only to property taxes collected by a town from taxpayers and does not extend to any State aid for town highways. Any town that takes advantage of this allowance must pay back the amount it borrows to the fund borrowed from, together with whatever interest the selectboard deems appropriate.
No, at least not during the declared state of emergency. The recently enacted Act 92 clearly states that a “municipality shall be prohibited from disconnecting a person from water or sewer services during a declared state of emergency under 20 V.S.A. chapter 1 due to COVID-19.” Towns can use other collection methods at their disposal (e.g. small claims court, distraint, tax sale, etc.), but they cannot disconnect users so long as the current state of emergency remains in place.
Are there any reimbursements available to towns for expenses incurred in response to the COVID-19 outbreak?
Yes. On March 13, President Trump issued an emergency declaration authorizing FEMA to reimburse states, tribes, and territories of the United States for “eligible emergency protective measures taken to respond to the COVID-19 emergency” at the 75 percent federal cost share. See (copy and paste this link into your browser): https://www.fema.gov/news-release/2020/03/13/covid-19-emergency-declaration.
Towns are encouraged to track all costs related to responding to COVID-19. Please visit Vermont Emergency Management’s Coronavirus Information for Local Officials for the latest updates and contact Kimberly Canarecci, State Public Assistance Officer, at email@example.com or (802) 585-4209 with any FEMA reimbursement related questions.
On June 15, the Governor enacted Act 108 (H.951) which established the Municipal Emergency Statewide Education Property Tax Program. This program authorizes the State Treasurer to assist municipalities by making payments on the costs of short-term borrowing required to manage the cash flow effects of statewide education property tax deferrals as a result of the COVID-19 pandemic. See the State Treasurer’s website for application materials and answers to frequently asked questions about the program: https://www.vermonttreasurer.gov/content/local-government
for grants to reimburse eligible COVID-19 expenses incurred by municipalities by December 30th, which is the deadline to spend CRF monies established in the federal Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act. Of the total $13 million, $12,650,000 is available to counties and local governments through the Local Government Expense Reimbursement (LGER) Grant. Local officials must be sure to document all of their expenditures incurred from managing the COVID-19 pandemic. The deadline for this grant application is September 4, 2020, all supporting documentation must be submitted on or before December 15, 2020, and all eligible expenses must be incurred by December 30, 2020.
Act 137 (H.966) also provides $2 million in grants to municipalities to digitize their land records provided they had to close their offices due to COVID-19 and they’ve established and maintained a Restoration and Preservation Reserve Fund. Grants will be awarded based on need and whether they will have a meaningful impact on the ability of the public to access digitized land records online. The Agency of Administration has published guidelines for the Coronavirus Municipal Records Digitization Grant. The deadline for this grant application is also September 1, 2020 and all supporting documentation must be submitted on or before December 15, 2020. Eligible expenses must be incurred by December 30, 2020.
Guidelines for both of these grants including information about things to do before you apply, eligibility of applicants and expenditures, and the application process are all available on the VT Department of Taxes’ website at: tax.vermont.gov/coronavirus/municipal-grants Be sure your documents are in order so you can apply for and receive full reimbursement for these eligible expenses as soon as possible. Any questions on grant eligibility or how to apply can be directed to the Director of the Division of Property Valuation and Review, Jill Remick, at firstname.lastname@example.org
Are any of these federally funded grant programs available for reimbursing municipalities for hazard pay?
Yes, the Local Government Expense Reimbursement (LGER) Grant (see above) created by Act 137 includes hazard pay as an eligible expense. Please visit tax.vermont.gov/coronavirus/municipal-grants for more information.
Note that the Front-Line Employees Hazard Grant Program, created by Act 136, and associated guidance provided by the Agency of Human Services state that a “[c]overed employer does not include: the state, a political subdivision of the state…” Therefore, as a political subdivision of the state, municipalities are not eligible for this grant to obtain reimbursement for hazard pay resulting from COVID-19.
Yes. The federal Small Business Administration (SBA) is making emergency loans available to businesses in most of the state. Business located in the 10 declared counties (Addison, Bennington, Caledonia, Chittenden, Essex, Grand Isle, Orange, Rutland, Windham, and Windsor) can immediately apply for assistance online at: https://disasterloan.sba.gov/ela/. The VT Agency of Commerce and Community Development (ACCD) anticipates the 4 remaining counties (Franklin, Lamoille, Orleans, and Washington) to receive a designation shortly. For more information, call the SBA disaster assistance customer service center at 1-800-659-2955 (TTY: 1-800-877-8339) or e-mail email@example.com. For local SBA information, call 802-828-4422.
The Vermont Small Business Development Center (VtSBDC) is providing technical assistance to help guide small businesses through the COVID-19 crisis. Requests for assistance can be directed to: https://www.vtsbdc.org/coronavirus/.
ACCD is interested in hearing from all Vermont businesses affected by COVID-19 so that it may assess its full impact. The Agency has developed an Agency Business Impact Form available at: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/vtcovid19 to aid this process. It also has a dedicated hotline for businesses to report impacts and inquire about available resources: (802) 461-5143. The hotline will be staffed from Monday to Friday, 7:45 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. Business related COVID-19 questions should be e-mailed to the Agency at: firstname.lastname@example.org.